Case Study

How a regional retailer consolidated three competing strategies into one.

When every devision had a different definition of success, forward momentum became impossible. We helped a 900-person retail organization align around a single direction, and build the governance to keep it that way.

Share this case study

LinkedIn Email
The Challenge

Three divisions. 

Three strategies.
No shared direction.

This retailer had grown through acquisition without ever building a unified strategic foundation. By the time we engaged, the organization had momentum–but no agreed upon direction to aim it.

The problems weren’t new. Leadership had recognized them for years. What was missing was a process to surface and resolve the disagreements underneath them.

  • Leadership misalignment ran deep

    Each division operated on its own growth plan with its own resource requests. Every cross-functional conversation became a negotiation–
and every allocation decision reopened the same unresolved debates.

  • Plans existed. Alignments didn’t.

    Previous planning cycles had produced documents, not conviction. Strategies sat in decks nobody references, with commitments nobody was accountable for following through on.

  • The wrong problem was being solved.

    The presenting issue was execution–projects stalling, decisions slow. 
But the real problem was upstream: no shared definition of what the organization was trying to become.

Our Approach

Surfacing the real disagreements before building a strategy.

  • 1

    Diagnosis before deliverables

    Structured interviews across leadership, division heads, and managers revealed the disagreements weren’t about priorities–they were about identity.

  • 2

    Facilitated alignment–not consensus-building

    A structured workshop series focused on genuine decisions: which markets, what experience to deliver, and what the organization was explicitly choosing not to do.

  • 3

    A framework that translates across divisions

    Each division’s priorities anchored to shared enterprise goals with explicit tradeoff logic that leadership agreed to in advance.

  • 4

    Building the governance to sustain it

    A quarterly review rhythm embedded with internal capability to run it–so the work continued after we left, led entirely by the client’s own team.

Value Delivered

A single strategy the organization actually uses.

Unified framework with decision rights

Leadership aligned on shared goals with explicit 
tradeoff logic–ending years of divisional conflict 
over resource allocation.

Sustained governance process

A quarterly strategy review rhythm implemented and run independently by the client team for over a year since the engagement ended.

Divisional priorities reconnected 
to enterprise goals

Each division’s plan restructured to link directly to 
shared objectives, eliminating the primary source 
of cross-functional friction.

Capability built inside the organization

Strategic planning embedded in how decisions get made–not handed off as a document, but practiced as an ongoing organizational discipline.

Results that reflect the work behind them.

3 1

Competing divisional 
plans consolidated into 
one unified framework.

92%

Client-led implementation rate after the Gunter Group engagement ended.

14mo

From engagement start to full organizational adoption.

>
The Gunter Group didn’t come in with a pre-determined answer. They spent the first few weeks asking questions, and that’s exactly what we needed. We had been solving the wrong
problem for two years.”
– VP of Digital Commerce Specialty Retail Company

Related Insights

Case Study
Strategy Retail

They went 30 years without a strategy. We built one in four months.

Read more
Case Study
Strategy Government

Turning a newly assembled leadership team into one team.

Read more
Case Study
Strategy Education

Turning an operating loss to a $1.8 million opportunity.

Read more
See all insights & perspectives
Work With Us

The firms that move fastest don’t wait for clarity. They create it.

We help leadership teams cut their ambiguity, align around what matters, and build the momentum to transform their business.

Let's talk